Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frank Moore's avatar

This essay was the most subtley dense piece you’ve written imo. I came away from it with a value judgment that while both principled, Goldberg‘s position is less so than Longwell and Miller’s. It is my belief that Goldberg’s principled position is marred by too rigid an ideology, one which seems to have lost almost all purchase among what’s left of the GOP. I’ve always considered myself an FDR Democrat even though I was born well after FDR passed away. The reason for this view was based primarily on the knowledge I gained growing up lower middle class that my grandfather and his son, my dad, benefitted directly from New Deal policies. By the time I went to college, Keynesianism was replaced by Milton Friedman and the case for dismantling the New Deal was ushered in by Reaganism then assisted along by Democrats themselves in the adoption of neo-liberalism. Now that destruction has reached it’s apex with the adoption of nihlistic authoritarianism. So, here’s the irony I find myself in: like Goldberg, I continue to cling to an ideology that has lost all purchase but I still hold out for it’s return. Principled? Maybe. Delusional? Likely. But what I discovered along the way is that I really like the Bulwark crowd and still find the likes of Goldberg humorless bores. Also, it should be noted that the critique of both Longwell and Miller came from Andrew Sullivan who I consider to be one of the biggest pompous asses ever to exist.

Bradley  K Monson's avatar

There are those who know better and say nothing. And there are those who know better and do the things that keep them intellectually and morally honest.

The latter gets criticized for taking a stand while the former watches and takes note.

All the while the rest of the world is too stupid to realize just what happened.

Sadly, this is the world we live in…

11 more comments...

Ready for more?