13 Comments
User's avatar
Frank Moore's avatar

This essay was the most subtley dense piece you’ve written imo. I came away from it with a value judgment that while both principled, Goldberg‘s position is less so than Longwell and Miller’s. It is my belief that Goldberg’s principled position is marred by too rigid an ideology, one which seems to have lost almost all purchase among what’s left of the GOP. I’ve always considered myself an FDR Democrat even though I was born well after FDR passed away. The reason for this view was based primarily on the knowledge I gained growing up lower middle class that my grandfather and his son, my dad, benefitted directly from New Deal policies. By the time I went to college, Keynesianism was replaced by Milton Friedman and the case for dismantling the New Deal was ushered in by Reaganism then assisted along by Democrats themselves in the adoption of neo-liberalism. Now that destruction has reached it’s apex with the adoption of nihlistic authoritarianism. So, here’s the irony I find myself in: like Goldberg, I continue to cling to an ideology that has lost all purchase but I still hold out for it’s return. Principled? Maybe. Delusional? Likely. But what I discovered along the way is that I really like the Bulwark crowd and still find the likes of Goldberg humorless bores. Also, it should be noted that the critique of both Longwell and Miller came from Andrew Sullivan who I consider to be one of the biggest pompous asses ever to exist.

Frank Moore's avatar

Yes. I received a BA in economics myself in 1984. Moved to San Francisco since and have always considered myself left as defined by the anti-New Deal right. But since the rise of neo-liberalism in the Democratic Party followed by the Neo-authoritarianism of MAGA, I’ve put away childish things in splitting hairs over policy differences. I welcome DSA Dems, moderate Dems, Blue dog Dems and Never-Trump Republicans if they’re aligned in defeating fascism at home and abroad. If we ever get back to debating a rival political party over tax policy and the size of the welfare state again, I will consider it a success. I’m not holding my breath. I’m holding my enemy’s enemies close.

Michael Taylor's avatar

San Franciscan as well...since I moved here in 1982. It saddens me to have seen the conservative push driven by the enormous wealth and money what has washed over the City, with the billionaire class driving an Insta-Mayor catering to their money (and his momma's money). Sure, he ran a non-profit -- but, hey, a functioning society should not have to depend on philanthropists that get more back in tax dollars than they contribute "to the public good" and even get to direct where that money is spent -- eg, Chris Larsen donating all the surveillance cameras pushing the City further into a police state. Not very democratic -- the public should have taxed him and determined where the money would have spent.

Maybe I've just become a curmudgeonly old leftist...

Frank Moore's avatar

You know, I almost went back to Southern California because SF was so expensive even back in the late 80’s. I’m glad I didn’t. But watching Hong Kong money (first wave when HK was going back to China), the http://dot.com bubble followed by institutional investors post 2008 melt down drive up property values pale by comparison to the tech bro nouveau riche recent travesty (several months ago 40 SF properties were bid up $1M over asking) particularly since many of them are dark enlightenment fascists. It’s a complete slap in the face to the history of the place. Even past Barbary Coast practitioners of Shanghaiing were more honortable than these cretins.

Michael Taylor's avatar

Agreed - but I may have gone further left. Graduating in ‘81 with an economics degree heavily influenced by a professor mentored by Friedman, I came out near libertarian, but for different reasons - I saw my father eaten up and destroyed in his middle management job at Burlington Industries in the ‘70s, and vowed never to submit myself to such endeavors. I was even told by my own mentor at C&S Bank in Atlanta, a southern gentleman who led their PR group, that maybe corporate life was not for me.

Then, I turned sharply left in the 80s, realizing even then that wealth concentration was becoming an abomination, and voted for Jessie Jackson in the CA presidential primaries. I saw even then the overlapping similarities of both of the major parties.

I loathed Clinton, and every neoliberal since..maybe to my own detriment…but I am modestly enheartened by the recent rise of the DSA and their push. Will corporate America and corporate media allow them to grow more than they have already? I doubt it…but for our country’s sake, I hope so.

History shows that when the bottom becomes too oppressed, revolution happens. And when revolution happens, all bets are off on what follows…

Bradley  K Monson's avatar

There are those who know better and say nothing. And there are those who know better and do the things that keep them intellectually and morally honest.

The latter gets criticized for taking a stand while the former watches and takes note.

All the while the rest of the world is too stupid to realize just what happened.

Sadly, this is the world we live in…

Andy the Alchemist's avatar

My position is that you should always vote to limit the amount of suffering in the world. Sitting on your hands when the moral choice was so absurdly easy in 2024 just makes the fence sitters look like clowns in my eyes.

Rick Knight's avatar

I loathe Goldberg's position. All the faux-profound riddle-rhetoric doesn't change the fact that Trump is an evil and stupid man, and the outcomes of his election were 100% foreseeable. The write-in vote for Paul Ryan was an act of philsophical masturbation.

EG's avatar
1dEdited

What are “the foreseeable results of [Goldberg’s] abstention,” in your mind? Your post seems to suggest that the foreseeable result is the election of people like President Trump. I don’t think Goldberg has that kind of persuasive impact on American politics. For that matter, I don’t think the writers at The Bulwark have more than a marginal impact on election results either. If I’m right, how does that affect your view of the ethics of their approaches?

Mike Brock's avatar

Well, this is intellectual commentary on political commentary, and it is decidedly removed from any attempt to measure the impact on electoral politics. And while my writing often ventures into polemic, I almost never write from that frame.

Jennifer Anderson's avatar

This is the best write up of the discourse yet.

Dan's avatar

Great article. As someone who tends towards pragmatism, I am usually drawn to the Longwell position, which is essentially "choose the lesser of evils". But I have extreme doubts about this. A couple of hypotheticals to illustrate:

(1) Imagine a society in which the rulers have decided there are to be only two permitted options: to worship as a Muslim or make an open declaration to all that you are an atheist. If you are a committed Christian, what do you do? Openly declare that God does not exist, or go to the mosque and worship Allah (because at least Muslims acknowledge that Jesus existed)? Which is the 'lesser of evils'? Both result in you effectively endorsing the validity of the choice.

(2) Imagine you land in a place where the only food made available is beef or chicken. You are a committed vegetarian. Which is the 'lesser of evils'? Eat the chicken because it is a less sentient animal than a cow? Or starve? If you starve and die then nothing changes as far as the suppliers of food are concerned, again you have effectively endorsed the system.

To me it seems both lead to the Goldberg position which is to stick with your principles you have to refuse both options, regardless of the consequences?

Mr Rob's avatar

Gobbledygook at best. You’re too talented to spend time dissecting this topic. I respect you trying and thanks for sharing.

And as an old guy, I’ll never respect anything Bill Kristol says and I will laugh with Billy Crystal.