4 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Stephen Strum, MD, FACP's avatar

Nikhil, you said:

"You may disagree with many of these but every one of them has a strong rationale."

Me: Wrong Nikhil. I can agree with all of the above. But you have been conned by the wheeler-dealer, and, to use his own vocabulary, a pathologic liar like "never before."

You have not been to a communist country as far as I know (maybe your real name is Nikita and not Nikhil). You were not in the USSR (I think). You do not throw Ukraine under the bus and hand its people and Democracy to Vladimir Putin. You do not insult a country's honestly elected president the way Trump insulted Zelensky. You do not negotiate a deal of rare-earth minerals for aid to Ukraine. Yes, you do ask for Germany, Netherlands, the Scandinavian countries, etc to pay up a fair share into NATO. But you do not alienate allies and pay tribute to murderers like Putin, Kim-Jong-Un.

Agreed that Social Media has major/serioius downsides but you do not handcuff a foreign student on a visa for pro-Palestinian written or verbal statements. I think Trump is a Fascist, clear and simple. Do you imprison me, send me off to Louisiana or El Salvador without due process. The loss of due process is the first sign of Fascism. Do you take away free speech a la Marko Rubio? That is another side of a fascist regime. You you attack the Press as did Trump with the Associated Press, or attack the editor-in-chief for being effin stupidly invited to a non-secure top secret SIGNAL chat as did Mike Waltz by Trump's pick fo NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISOR.

I agree about the excessive emphasis on transgender issues, especially male transgendering to female and participating in women's sports. Ridiculous & should not be allowed. I couldn't care less if public restrooms were open to any sex as they have been in Europe for many decades. But I am sick of all the homosexulaity displayed in my face in the media, which I believe is part of the spectrum of how Hollywood has effed up morality and/or decency. Be a homosexual or heterosexual, but do not shove it in my face with TV ads or movies or other broadcasts.

Where you are wrong is on the energy issue. Climate change is not a scam. Disease and premature death from pollution of air, water, and earth is not and this is heavily detailed in many publications. There are ways to obtain energy using safer community-size thorium or other isotope reactors. Adjuncts like solar and wind (or tidal) energy are exactly that- adjuncts. The world context has changed and with it oceans have devolved, as has the ozone layer.

Your items #1 and 2 are legitimate, but not the way Trump is going about them, sending helter-skelter citizens and non-citizens to El Salvador or Louisiana without due process. That's fascist.

Reduce government spending by tearing apart and rendering inefficient every government agency is overkill. It would be like me seeing an obese patient and immediately deciding to put them on a starvation diet without first seeing where the problem(s) have arisen from. That example, Nikhil, deserves reproach: warning- warning: bullshit alert. But great example of putting the fox in the henhouse.

I do not know if we can find common ground between our views. I would welcome an open debate between you and me anytime. But I would speculate, that if I suggested we have a panel of fact-checkers to discern bullshit when spoken, you would not agree to this.

The devil is in the details. "The facts, ma'am, just the facts." Or, as Mike says, 2+2 =4 and there are 24 hrs in a day (unless you are on Mars).

Expand full comment
Nikhil Mehta's avatar

Someday maybe we can debate and find common ground. Since you have already decided the outcome of Trump’s actions and I am willing to wait, it is a seemingly pointless exercise at this time.

Expand full comment
Stephen Strum, MD, FACP's avatar

Agreed.

But a fascist takeover is no time to "let's see what he does." If you see further evidence of such behavior, you may be living in Putin's Russia or Erdoğan's Turkey.

We will both see what has happened this time next month and the June thereafter.

▶︎ What has happened to the wars in Ukraine and Gaza?

▶︎ What is the state of the US and world economy?

▶︎ Are children still dying of measles?

▶︎ Is there any improvement in healthcare?

As is said, I will bend a knee or two if any of the above have been accomplished successfully.

Expand full comment
Nikhil Mehta's avatar

I have to ask. Do you even know what fascist means? Your continuous use of the term makes me believe you are not serious.

Expand full comment