Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jeff's avatar

Why is China our intractable enemy, that we should salivate for war with (economically at the very least, perhaps militarily)? I’ve yet to see you offer anything but the vaguest suggestions on this question. Is it that there’s bound to be a brutal global hegemon, so it might as well be us? You believe that global dominance by a superpower is inevitable, and you prefer the dominion of US elites (convenient that you happen to be a member of the US elite, albeit a fringe one) rather than Chinese elites? Grandiose, zero sum, thoroughly neoconservative thinking.

Expand full comment
srod1998's avatar

The alternative was what? Our entire circumstance was created by the elites who have ran our institutions since at least 2008. There are SOOOOO many variables the author leaves out of his short piece, which I will give him the benefit of the doubt was meant for brevity. This would include and not be limited to other geo-political actors opposed to China (India); the damage done to our allies own markets if they begin selling off dollars or treasuries (owe the bank 1000 that's a problem for me, owe the bank a million that's a problem for the bank); our opponents own debt issues; the lack of soft power for China; the deep, historic animosities between China and Japan, or South Korea; many allies will prefer to wait Trump out, see if the next administration is different.......or simply that China miscalculates - they attack Taiwan with a military strike that is incompetent like Russia's and every Pacific nation gets CLOSER to the US instead of cutting a deal with the new hegemon. (A) Yes we are in big trouble; (B) these problems were created by everyone BEFORE Trump; and (C) never bet against the Americans.

Expand full comment
37 more comments...

No posts