Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Strum, MD, FACP's avatar

Years ago, Harry Nilsson wrote a "child's album) called "The Point." it was chock-full of philosophical wisdom about the nature of human behavior. Example: "you see what you want to see; you hear what you want to hear."

I am a "crime" scene investigator-- in reality a physician but I liken my job as a CSI. In my medical presentations, I would often say I am a MD (medical detective), a Charley Chan, MD, with focus on reviewing your past and current data and being able to guide you in your challenge of a cancer diagnosis.

Mike, you wrote in today's post: "The signs are there for anyone willing to see them: the escalating rhetoric, the institutional erosion, the economic brinkmanship, the framing of disagreement as existential threat."

I was part of a diplomatic delegation to the USSR in 1986 after Chernobyl. I was secreted into private homes to see patients with cancer; I sat with them in their apartments, heard what they could say openly without fear of being monitored, and noted what books they were reading. From the cab drivers I conversed with, to those people I could speak freely to, I realized the oppression they lived under. I also felt that the very same people were far better read and had a broader knowledge of many things compared to their American counterparts.

Fast-forward to 2024. I am emailing back and forth with a medical colleague in Moscow. He tells me he has full Internet access. Yet, for him, Ukraine had to be de-Nazified, and in his political perception, Putin had done no wrong. I replied to him with facts, but he would not budge. like some of my colleagues, family, and neighbors. It seems that one party or the other has been brain-washed, or "drank the cool-aid." Yet, my research about Trump has spanned 9 years as of now. I have read books written more than 20 years ago about the vile and corrupt nature of Trump (Wayne Barrett- Google him). I was appalled at the puerile utterings of Trump and the stupidity he manifested during COVID-19, about which I consider myself to have significant expertise. Where this country is right NOW is far worse than most Americans realize.

We are in the midst of a fascist administration. Due process, freedom of speech, attacks on the Press, and now threats of deportation of American citizens are here. We have a moronic and sociopathic POTUS and a GOP that either is shockingly stupid or consumed by a need for power. And we have an electorate, even those in a lower socio-ecomomic class, and who are in the very strata attacked by Trump et al. (e.g., women, Hispanics, Blacks, Veterans) who seem blind to the malignancy of the Trump/GOP rhetoric and actions.

We are in a Dicken's novel- We have seen the best of times, and now we are in the worst of times. Trump and his followers will destroy America. The land of opportunity is to become the Land of Opportunists. The electorate of any country must be fully invested in the health of a nation by its actions. It cannot stand by passively and assume a righteous, moral, and capable Captain and crew are piloting the ship of state.

Expand full comment
Cindy's avatar

I struggle daily with "seeing" things my friends don't. I feel like Cassandra. It is both heartening and discouraging to realize that someone with your depth & breadth of knowledge, and power to persuade, still finds that they are unable to overcome, in their friend's minds, the power of media lies.

Expand full comment
72 more comments...

No posts